A New Yorker's Guide to Growing Juicy Tomatoes

Close-up of a basket filled with freshly harvested tomatoes

Where it Fits in NYC

List all icons of attributes directly under header image above like: container sizes, indoor/outdoor, hydroponic, spaces, click here to get seeds, difficulty, pollinator, cool/warm weather, perennial/annual, best month to plant, best month to harvest, etc.

Why I Grow It

I grow tomatoes because store-bought tomatoes usually lack that deep, sun-warmed flavor. They are bred for durability rather than taste. Growing my own I know they are pesticide-free, cost-effective, and incredibly convenient. Since my space is limited, I use companion planting.  I grow basil, marigolds and arugula right along side tomatoes, because they enhance the flavor, repel pests and fill gaps so I get the max out of my small garden.  Plucking a sun-warmed, juicy tomato right from your own urban garden is a delight that makes city life feel a little more grounded.

get your seeds now

Growth Essentials

Light

Tomatoes require 6-8 hours of direct sunlight daily.

Indoors: Stick to dwarf varieties and use bright light or hydroponically with grow lights for 12-14 hours.

Water

Water regularly to keep soil evenly moist. Indoors, air can dry soil quickly; outdoors, water regularly, especially during hot weather. Mulching helps retain moisture.

Temperature

Tomatoes are a warm weather crop and thrive in 70-85°F, ideally 75-80°F. Plant outdoors in May-June in NYC zone 7b. Warm, sunny conditions are essential for ripening.

Containers

Indoors: 14-16" wide, 14" deep, 7-10 gallons (grow dwarf varieties only).

Outdoors: 14-18" wide, 14-18" deep, 7-10 gallons.

Soil

Tomatoes prefer rich, well-draining potting mix with compost from kitchen scraps or well-rotted manure.

Fertilizer

Apply balanced 10-10-10 early and high-phosphorus 5-10-10 during flowering.

Organic Options: compost, fish emulsion, bone meal. Fertilize every 2-3 weeks, avoid excessive nitrogen.

Harvesting Tips

Remove suckers and lower leaves to improve airflow and sunlight exposure. Regular pruning promotes healthy growth and fruit production.

Harvest Time

Long: 12-15 Weeks

Freshly harvested tomatoes held in both hands
Close-up of a basket filled with freshly harvested tomatoes

Common Growing Issues

Why are my leaves turning yellow?

Why It's Happening:

This is usually a sign of overwatering or a lack of food. In NYC, small pots run out of nutrients quickly, especially after a heavy rain.

How to Fix It:

Make sure your pot has drainage holes. Feed your plant a balanced 10-10-10 food. Mix in worm castings to keep the soil rich and healthy.

What are these tiny bugs on the stems?

Why It's Happening:

Aphids love the warm, sheltered microclimates of NYC balconies and rooftops. They drink the sap and weaken the plant.

How to Fix It:

Buy ladybugs to release on your tomatoes to eat the aphids! You can also spray the bugs off with a strong stream of water in your sink.

Why is my tomato plant wilting?

Why It's Happening:

Tomatoes are very thirsty. The heat from NYC concrete and bricks can dry out a large tomato plant in just half a day.

How to Fix It:

Water your plants deeply in the morning. If the leaves droop every afternoon, you may need a larger pot. Adding compost helps the soil hold onto water longer.

Why is my plant growing so slowly?

Why It's Happening:

Tomatoes need at least 8 hours of direct sun. Tall buildings often block the light, which stops the plant from growing fruit.

How to Fix It:

Move your plant to the sunniest spot you have. Use a 5-10-10 plant food to help the plant focus on growing tomatoes instead of just long vines.

Why are the leaves turning brown and dying?

Why It's Happening:

This is likely Blight. It spreads fast in NYC because the air is sticky and does not move well between tall buildings.

How to Fix It:

Cut off the sick leaves immediately and throw them in the trash. Use beneficial nematodes in the soil to help keep the plant strong against diseases.

Grows Together With (Companion Planting)

Health & Nutrition Spotlight

Tomatoes are famous for lycopene, an antioxidant that helps protect skin from sun damage and supports a healthy heart.

Curated Gear For Growing

Still have questions?

I'm here to help!